Paul G. Zareith

Shadows Over Kaighal

Joanna Maciejewska

2025-07-13

My Review

This review will be relatively short because this is the third book of the series. You absolutely need to read the other two before this one - and if you have made it this far, you are likely already invested in the plot and characters. All the attributes about this series that I have been raving about in my reviews for the first and the second, do carry over in this book too. The plot is fast-paced and action-packed.

Having said that, I think this is the book where much of the world-building we see in the first book truly begins to shine. So far this is my favorite in the series, but I have a feeling I’ll be singing a different tune once I have read the next book, which brings us to a conclusion.

The second book took a step back from the sprawling world-building that we saw in the first to focus on Kamira’s quest against the high mages. Now that that is behind us, quite a few tangents that I had been waiting for actually begin to unfold. And new, interesting players who had been sitting on the sidelines step up their game. In addition, some of the characters who hadn’t been as interesting in the first two, rise up to their full potential.

Even though she is now at the helm of Kaighal, and a powerful ancient demon is backing her with all his might, Kamira still has an unfathomably long list of challenges before her. The demon army is all set to encroach upon Kaighal, and neighbors from all sides are ready to take advantage of the turmoil. This is a book about action, politics, and treachery---and boy does it deliver!

‘She stared at the icy corpse, trying to conjure some appropriate feelings, but the only one to manifest was relief.’

I had been eagerly waiting for the four demon protectors worshipped by Tiravashan to make an appearance, and in this book they finally do. Also, for the first time we get a good look into the inner machinations of the Gildya Magna, politics on the Tiravashan side, and the Yalari power-games. And it all comes together really well.

The western kingdom emerges as a new threat, and Ryell getting entangled with them was an interesting tangent I didn’t see coming. But it was good to see Ryell discover his backbone and Atissa evolve into a more interesting character. Veek’s timely arrival was something I did anticipate, but still it was incredibly satisfying. And Kamira and Koshmarnyk, of course, remain an amazing duo through and through---her treatment of the Tivarashan entourage was fun.

‘And if she were a woman who prided herself on higher morality, this would be the time to show her benevolence, but since the first archmage of the High Towers was foolish enough to use deception after losing a fair duel, he didn’t deserve mercy.’

My only complaint at this point is that I wish the book had a glossary or linked to a wiki. I kept forgetting the names of the minor demons and side-characters, and while the author does do a great job at linking back to the past references wherever needed most of the times, at points I did feel it would have been good to have a concise reference.

And of course, right as soon as the demons actually arrive in the city---the book ends. Yes, after that cliffhanger in the second book, I should have seen it coming. Well, I didn’t! So forward we march towards the finale.

‘There’s coin in being curious.’

Paul G. Zareith

I am a sci-fi & fantasy author and avid fiction lover dabbling in the grimdark, gothic, arcane and all things forbidden and forgotten.

Share suggestions and feedback at [email protected]